Handmade Baked Goods

Count on the staff at Simply Sara’s to provide you with incredible handmade baked goods.

Our one-of-a-kind handmade cookies and delectables are made to order and feature a crunchy goodness you will not find anywhere else.  Our menu includes an assortment of cookies and brownies that satisfy everyone’s “goodie” loving taste buds. Call us today at (904) 387-1000 to ask about our products.

ALL FLAVORS ARE NOT AVAILABLE ALL THE TIME, IN ORDER TO ENSURE THE FRESHNESS OF OUR PRODUCTS.

Popular Menu Items

cookie-choc-chip
Chocolate Chip
This popular cookie is reminiscent of what your grandmother might make. They contain creamy semi-sweet chocolate chips that truly melt in your mouth. Our chocolate chip cookies are so light and crispy; you can eat the whole box in one sitting.
cookie-oatmeal-raisin
Oatmeal Raisin
As popular as our chocolate chip cookies, these cookies feature old-fashioned rolled oats, juicy raisins, just a hint of spices, and a glistening sugar covering. They are one of our chef’s favorites.
cookie-peanut-butter
Peanut Butter
We make thick and crunchy peanut butter cookies that are hand rolled in sugar and loaded with fresh peanut flavor.
cookie-white-choc-chip
White Chocolate Chip with Pecans
This is a kind, sweet, and good-hearted cookie. Some even call it the quintessential white chocolate chip cookie.  These cookies are crispy and light with a secret ingredient you’d never imagine in a recipe of these cookies. If you’re a white chocolate lover, these cookies are made for you!
cookie-oatmeal-snap
Oatmeal Snaps
We found the recipe for these cookies in our owner’s mother-in-law’s special recipe box. It was obviously written by someone from generations ago. This old-fashioned cookie is thin, light, and extremely crispy. They are meant to be eaten by the fistful.
cookie-brown-sugar
Brown Sugar Chewies (Blonde Brownies)
Our chewies feature the rich and decadent tastes of butter, brown sugar and pecans.  For the non-chocolate lover – and even chocolate lovers – these are to be eaten slowly and enjoyed with either a hot cup of coffee or a tall glass of ice-cold milk.
cookie-toffee-brownie
Toffee Brownies
We make rich, fudgy chocolate brownies topped with milk chocolate morsels and a generous sprinkling of toffee bits. They are a sure hit for anyone that might like a brownie with flair.
cookie-peanut-brownie-cup
Peanut Butter Brownie Cups
Our business offers a rich, chocolaty brownie “cupcake” with a peanut butter cup in the center. It’s the perfect ratio of chocolate to peanut butter.
cookie-candied-pecan
Candied Pecans
We feature candied pecans made with brown sugar and a hint of citrus. They are baked to a golden brown and enjoyed by anyone who happens to love pecans.

 

More Items are Available – Request a Full Menu Today

Basket Prices

  • Candied Pecans – $20.00 per Pound
  • Platters of Cookies – 3 Dozen Cookies with Your Choice of 3 Flavors
  Starting at $36.95
  • Basket of Cookies – 2 Dozen Cookies with Your Choice of 1 or 2 Flavors
  $26.95

Simply Sara’s also makes

  • Homemade Barbeque Sauce – $8.50
  • Pimento Cheese (in a variety of flavors)